By Robert L. Millet
The following is an essay by Robert L. Millet, professor of religion and emeritus dean of Religious Education at Brigham Young University. It can also be found on the LDS Newsroom Blog.
The issue of whether Latter-day Saints (Mormons) are Christian is not a new one, but the current media climate has caused the question to be revisited in both private and public conversations. No matter the circumstances, the underlying question is an important one and a matter whose implications reach well beyond the momentary news cycle.
In the early decades of the 19th century, upstate New York came to be known as the “Burnt Over District” during the second Great Awakening in American history. Many in that day were spiritual searchers, seekers who sought in earnest for “the ancient order of things.” This movement, known as Christian Primitivism or Restorationism, was made up of men and women who yearned for the simple Christianity of first century Galilean peasants, not what they saw as the sterile, creedalized and institutionalized religion the Christian church had become through the centuries. The two most successful products of this time were the Disciples of Christ, founded by Alexander Campbell, and The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, founded by Joseph Smith.
Joseph Smith explained that in his first vision, he was instructed to join none of the existing churches in the area, since they were believing in incorrect doctrines and lacked the apostolic power given to Peter and the apostles by Jesus (Matthew 16:13-19), and because God intended to bring about the scripturally-promised “restitution of all things” (Acts 3:21). Obviously this announcement was not received enthusiastically by pastors and priests and religious scholars of the day and became the rub between traditional Christianity and what the Mormons know as the “restored gospel.” That wedge has been in place for almost two centuries now. Joseph Smith’s ministry continued for 24 years after his first vision (he was murdered in June of 1844), and the Latter-day Saints remained an object of interest, curiosity and suspicion during that time. The movement west under the leadership of Brigham Young, Joseph’s successor, allowed the Saints to be isolated in the valley of the Great Salt Lake and to establish their “Zion,” a spiritual commonwealth. The 20th century dawned upon a Mormonism that was ready to become a contributing partner in America’s pluralistic society.
It’s worth noting that the cry of “Mormons are not Christian” was not something heard very often, if at all, during the days of Joseph Smith. People knew that the faith of the Latter-day Saints was in fact quite different than their own, that the followers of Joseph Smith believed in doctrinal matters that deviated from “traditional” Christianity, but folks seemed to assume that Mormonism fit under the umbrella of Christianity. I grew up in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, during the 1950s and 1960s. Most of my friends were either Southern Baptist or Roman Catholic. We spoke of religion occasionally and knew that doctrinal differences existed between us, but it would never have occurred to my buddies to exclude me and my family, or the other Latter-day Saints in our area for that matter, from the category of Christian. Simply put, we were Christian. My first encounter with the fact that there were people in the world who considered us to be non-Christian or that we constituted a “cult” came while I was serving as a young full-time missionary for the Church in the eastern United States. In those days conservative Protestants would meet us at the door with a copy of Walter Martin’s Kingdom of the Cults (1965). I think I had never heard the word cult before that time, and I certainly had never been told that I wasn’t Christian. Such sentiments spread within the evangelical Christian world during the 1980s with the release of Ed Decker’s movie The Godmakers, an anti-Mormon production one Presbyterian minister in Arizona called “religious pornography” for how it turned the sacred into the profane.
Questions and Answers
Well, that’s a bit of background. Let me now pose and respond briefly to some questions that are frequently asked. I am not an officer of the Church, nor do I speak with any authority beyond my own word. But I am a member of the faith in good standing, a serious student of the teachings and beliefs of the faith, and a professor of religion at the Church’s flagship academic institution, Brigham Young University, for the last 29 years.
1. Why do Mormons insist they are Christian?
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is built upon the person, power, divine Sonship and teachings of Jesus Christ. He is our Savior, our Lord and our God. Salvation comes in and through Him and in no other way. He alone has the power to forgive sins, cleanse hearts and raise people from the dead. He is also the great Exemplar, the model for happiness and the abundant life.
2. Do Latter-day Saints want to be included within traditional Christianity?
Although we have many things in common with different denominations, we are not a part of Roman Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, or Protestant Christianity. Instead, we claim that ours is an entirely different expression of original Christianity—restored Christianity.
3. Then why do you want to be called Christian when you are not really a part of historical Christianity?
I am not bothered very much when I am speaking with religious scholars or ministers and they suggest that Mormons are not Christians; they are generally speaking theologically or historically. Because Mormons do not hold to or accept as spiritually binding the decisions and formulations of the post-New Testament church councils (Nicaea, Constantinople, Ephesus), and because we believe in an expanded canon of scripture, they do not consider us to be a part of “orthodox” Christianity. They are correct. On the other hand, when the man on the street or the woman in the pew hears the words “Mormons are not Christian,” what do they make of it? Do they think it means that Mormons do not accept the divinity of Jesus, do not accept the message and witness of the New Testament, do not believe that Jesus suffered and died for our sins, do not believe that He rose from the dead into glorious immortality? If they were to draw any of those conclusions, they would be incorrect and thereby misunderstand, misperceive and thereafter misrepresent the faith and beliefs held by their Latter-day Saint friends.
A few years ago I was in New York City and met with the late Father Richard John Neuhaus, a respected conservative voice among Roman Catholics. We conversed cordially for almost an hour, and he spoke fondly of the Mormon/Evangelical dialogue that had been underway for a decade.
Meridian Cares Alert: Largest Fire in Washington State History: Immediate Needs from Meridian Readers